| Average | Player | Rounds | Years |
| 70.69* | Bryce Molder | 147 | 1997-01 |
| 70.96 | Ollie Schniederjans | 144 | 2011-15 |
| 71.37 | Luke Schniederjans | 114 | 2016-20 |
| 71.47 | Noah Norton | 73 | 2017-20 |
| 71.49 | Anders Albertson | 150 | 2011-15 |
| 71.54 | Andy Ogletree | 110 | 2016-20 |
| 71.65 | Tyler Strafaci | 105 | 2016-20 |
| 71.81 | Cameron Tringale | 139 | 2005-09 |
| 71.83 | David Duval | 162 | 1989-93 |
| 71.86 | Matt Kuchar | 138 | 1996-2000 |
| 71.91 | Troy Matteson | 139 | 1998-03 |
| 71.92 | Roberto Castro | 143 | 2003-07 |
| 72.02 | Chan Song | 146 | 2001-05 |
| 72.05 | Nicholas Thompson | 143 | 2001-05 |
| 72.22 | Seth Reeves | 95 | 2010-14 |
| 72.37 | James White | 123 | 2008-12 |
| 72.38 | Chesson Hadley | 106 | 2006-10 |
| 72.47 | Kyle Scott | 106 | 2009-11 |
| 72.66 | Stewart Cink | 157 | 1991-95 |
| 72.67 | Chris Petefish | 111 | 2014-18 |
| 72.70 | Vincent Whaley | 92 | 2013-17 |
| 72.71 | Connor Howe | 45 | 2018-20 |
| 72.90 | Kris Mikkelsen | 101 | 1998-02 |
| 72.94 | John-Tyler Griffin | 122 | 2007-11 |
| 72.95 | James Clark | 107 | 2014-19 |
